Can Nonprofits Make a Profit? The Answer Might Surprise You

When people hear the term "nonprofit," they often assume these organizations can't—or shouldn't—make money. But the truth is more nuanced. Yes, nonprofits can generate profits, but how they use those funds is what sets them apart.

Let’s break down the myths, legalities, and smart strategies for financial sustainability.

1. Nonprofits Can Earn a Profit (Here’s How)

The Myth:

"Nonprofits must operate at a loss or break even."

The Reality:

Nonprofits can and should generate surplus revenue (a.k.a. "profit") to:
✅ Build reserves for emergencies or future growth
✅ Invest in programs, staff, or infrastructure
✅ Ensure long-term sustainability

Example: A nonprofit thrift store profits from sales but reinvests earnings into job training programs.

Key Rule: Profits cannot benefit private individuals (like shareholders)—they must fund the mission.

2. The IRS Rules on Nonprofit "Profit"

The IRS allows nonprofits to make money through:

Donations & grants (tax-deductible)
Earned income (e.g., selling goods/services related to the mission)
Investments (e.g., endowment funds)

⚠️ But Beware:

Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT): If revenue comes from activities unrelated to your mission (e.g., a museum running a café), it may be taxable.
Excessive salaries: Paying executives "too much" can trigger IRS scrutiny.

📌 Tip: The IRS Pub 557 outlines nonprofit profit rules.

3. How Smart Nonprofits Use Surplus Funds

Instead of calling it "profit," nonprofits use terms like "net revenue" or "operating surplus." Here’s how to allocate it wisely:

🔹 Rainy day funds (3–6 months of operating expenses)
🔹 Program expansion (e.g., adding a new community service)
🔹 Staff bonuses/raises (to retain talent—within reason)
🔹 Debt reduction (paying off loans saves long-term costs)

Case Study: Charity: Water builds 100% of donations into projects but funds overhead via separate "The Well" membership program.

4. What Not to Do With Nonprofit Revenue

🚫 Private benefit – Paying board members excessive fees or perks.
🚫 Hoarding cash – Sitting on huge reserves without a plan can alienate donors.
🚫 Ignoring UBIT – Forgetting to file taxes on unrelated income risks penalties.

💡 Pro Tip: The National Council of Nonprofits offers guides on surplus fund management.

Final Takeaway: Profit ≠ Greed

Nonprofits need financial health to sustain impact. The key difference? For-profits distribute profits to owners; nonprofits reinvest them into their cause.

💸 "Think nonprofits can’t make money? Think again! Here’s how they generate profit legally—and why it’s crucial for sustainability. Learn more

Share this article...

Facebook

Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn Pinterest Pocket Reddit Email

Want our best tax and accounting tips and insights delivered to your inbox?

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

Non-Profit Accounting is not a CPA firm and does not provide assurance services.